The Dancing Toaster Podcast

What is the Maryland Goatman? Is it an experiment gone wrong? Or something darker? What on earth is the Pope Lick monster? Why have so many died looking for him? Are these two connected? Why are there so many goat-human hybrid creatures in the legends and lore of the Americas? Do these things go back further than that? Join me in this episode where we answer these questions and so many more.
 
The Dancing Toaster is a weekly podcast that wrestles with the intersection of faith and the paranormal.
 
Wanna support the work I'm doing?
Donate at buymeacoffee.com/Thedancingtoaster
or join the Patreon and gain access to the new member exclusive show called The Man-Eating Toaster where I cover cults and true-crime-y things!

Did you know that New Jersey has a state demon? Who, or what is the Jersey Devil? Some say it’s a hoax, some say it’s a cursed mutated child, some say it’s political propaganda, while others say that it is something far worse. Don’t miss today’s episode of the Dancing Toaster where we’ll do a deep dive into one of America’s oldest cryptids.
 
The Dancing Toaster is a podcast that wrestles with the intersection of faith and the paranormal. I release new episodes every Tuesday morning on Apple, Spotify, and YouTube.
You can now support the work I’m doing through Patreon or BuyMeAcoffee.com/thedancingtoaster
If you join the Patreon you can gain early access and access to a brand new member exclusive show called the Man-eating Toaster where I cover cults and true crime-y things!
 

Who or what is the Mothman? What exactly happened during the 1960s in Point Pleasant? Has it happened before? Will it ever happen again? Was Mothman an alien? A failed experiment? An angel? A demon? Or perhaps a figment of people’s imagination? What are we to make of the infamous Mothman? Join me for our first deep dive on one of the most famous cryptids in the world to see if he is friend or foe, real or imagined.
 
The Dancing Toaster is a podcast that wrestles with the intersection of faith and the paranormal.
I release new episodes every Tuesday morning on Apple, Spotify, and YouTube.
 
This season we’ve been covering various cryptids and creatures throughout time and throughout the world. Hope to see you again next week!

What is the Mokele Mbembe? What are Thunderbirds and why are there so many accounts of them throughout the Americas? Why are there so many reports of large reptilian creatures around the globe in its most unexplored regions? We know that dinosaurs once roamed the earth, could they still be in some of its darkest corners? What if everything we’ve been told about dinosaurs, the age of the earth, and evolution is a lie?
 
Join me as we continue our exciting journey, part 2 of examining dinosaur like cryptids from around the globe.
 
The Dancing Toaster is a podcast that wrestles with the intersection of faith and the paranormal. I release new episodes every Tuesday morning on Apple, Spotify, and on YouTube.
 
You can now support the work I’m doing through Patreon or BuyMeAcoffee.com/thedancingtoaster
If you join the Patreon you can gain early access and access to a brand new member exclusive show called the Man-eating Toaster where I cover cults and true crime-y things!

Does Lake Chelan have a dragon? What could it be? Is it related to the Loch Ness Monster? Why are there reports of large reptilian creatures throughout time all around the globe? Did dragons once roam the earth? Where did they go? Did they ever leave?
Join me as we continue our exciting journey, part 1 of examining cryptids and dragons from around the globe.
The Dancing Toaster is a podcast that wrestles with the intersection of faith and the paranormal. I release new episodes every Tuesday morning on Apple, Spotify, and on YouTube.
You can now support the work I’m doing through Patreon or buymeacoffee.com/thedancingtoaster
 
If you join the Patreon we now have an exclusive show called the Man-Eating Toaster where I cover cults and true crime-y things!

Who or what are the Tah-Tah-Kle’-ah of the west coast? Who or what are the Stikini in the east? What do these Owl Monsters have to do with La Lechuza south of the border? Why do we find these Female owl cryptids everywhere we turn? Is this a modern phenomenon? Or are these monstrosities linked to something more ancient? Are they solely monsters, or at one time were they like you and me? Join me as we continue our exciting journey, examining cryptids and creatures from around the country and around the world.
 
The Dancing Toaster is a podcast that wrestles with the intersection of faith and the paranormal. I release new episodes every Tuesday morning on Apple, Spotify, and on YouTube.
Support the show at buymeacoffee.com/thedancingtoaster
or join the Patreon for access to the new exclusive show: The Man-Eating Toaster where I cover cults and true crime-y things

The series on Cryptids and Creatures starts in my own backyard, the beautiful and mysterious Pacific Northwest.
Who or what is Batsquatch? Is it an angel or demon? Is it related at all to Sasquatch? Could it be an undiscovered animal of some kind? Why did people only begin seeing it after the eruption of Mt St Helens? What does it have to do with other flying apelike creatures throughout the world? Like the Ahool and Orang Bati of Indonesia? These are just some of the questions we'll answer today.
 
The Dancing Toaster is a podcast that wrestles with the intersection of faith and the paranormal. I release new episodes every Tuesday morning on Apple, Spotify, and on YouTube.
 
support the show at buymeacoffee.com/thedancingtoaster
or join the Patreon for access to the new exclusive show: The Man-Eating Toaster where I cover cults and true crime-y things

Hello Toasters! I hope you're getting ready for season 2 launching on January 7th. Until then, here's something to hold you over.I told you last week in the final episode of season 1 that I was going to try and have a surprise for you before Christmas and I was able to get it ready.
Very few of you know that my ministry background didn’t start with preaching but with music, hopefully it doesn’t shock too many of you what kind…
It took a major backseat after my ordination, about a decade, but recently I tried to dust off the skills and merge them with what we do here on the show, and package it together for ya.
The instrumental was produced by Trunxks, you can find him on YouTube and social media under Trunxks beatz.
The song is called “Odyssey of the Mind”It’s inspired by both Homer’s Odyssey but with splashes of Pilgrim’s progress by John Bunyan
For the honor of the Prince of Peace our hero sets out on a journey through multiple treacherous environments to slay 3 ancient monsters.
The Tentacled Beast of Lazy can be found in the Pools of Stagnation.A Demonic host of fear is uncovered in the Forest of Uncertainty.And atop the highest peak in the land is the gold armored Titan named Pride who unsurprisingly has named the mountain after himself.Only with the aid of the prince of peace will our hero overcome these obstacles.
Thank you for the love the last 3 months, 2025 is coming and is going to be huge for the Dancing Toaster.
Some of you were asking earlier how you could help support the work I’m doing with the show.The Patreon has officially launched, if you can support monthly, the Toastie level is 5 bucks a month.I’m gonna be frank, the perks are still rolling out, right now it’s general support and will be ad free listening but there are many more things to come, next month and next year.
If you want to support the show by giving a one-time gift, the PayPal is also up and running now, simply give to:The Dancing Toaster
If you’re not able to support the work financially, I totally understand, I still appreciate all the love, thank you for listening to the show, and you sharing the show with others is impossible to put a price on, so thank you for that as well.
Don’t worry, the show will never be behind a paywall, but there will be awesome extras coming: discounts on merch, behind the scenes stuff, early access, and some live stuff too!
Please like, subscribe, follow, share, comment, and now you can even become a patron, do all the things you can wherever you consume the dancing toaster, but whatever you do, don’t consume toasters, and don’t consume any fruitcake, it’s probably from the 1950s simply in a new box, I love ya, I’m out!
 

Episode 12 of The Dancing Toaster concludes the harrowing case of Anneliese Michel, picking up where the previous episode left off. This installment examines the aftermath of her death, the controversial trial of her parents and priests, and the theological clash between faith, medicine, and supernatural belief. But it doesn’t stop there—this episode also delivers a sweeping critique of Roman Catholic theology, especially practices surrounding exorcism, Marian devotion, and the veneration of saints. It challenges the biblical legitimacy of the Rituale Romanum, relics, and the elevation of Mary as Queen of Heaven, tracing many of these traditions back to ancient paganism. With scripture-heavy rebuttals and unflinching analysis, it calls listeners to return to the sufficiency of Christ alone. This episode is not only the season finale—it’s a bold, controversial, and deeply personal exploration of spiritual truth, deception, and what real deliverance should look like.
The Dancing Toaster is a weekly podcast that wrestles with the intersection of faith and the paranormal.
Wanna support the work?
Buymeacoffee.com/thedancingtoaster
Or head over to the Patreon if you want access to the new member exclusive show: The Man-Eating Toaster

Episode 11 of The Dancing Toaster delves into one of the most disturbing and controversial exorcism cases in modern history: the possession and death of Anneliese Michel. The inspiration behind The Exorcism of Emily Rose, her story began with seizures and shadowy hallucinations and spiraled into a years-long ordeal filled with terrifying visions, spiritual torment, and a series of exorcisms that ultimately ended in tragedy. This episode covers it all—from her early symptoms and conflicting medical diagnoses to the dramatic escalation of supernatural events, including demonic voices, unnatural strength, and grotesque behaviors. Drawing from detailed accounts, official exorcism recordings, and diary entries allegedly inspired by visions of the Virgin Mary, the episode raises haunting questions: was Anneliese mentally ill, or was she possessed by something darker? It's a heart-wrenching, chilling examination of faith, suffering, and the terrifying space in between.
The Dancing Toaster is a weekly podcast that wrestles with the intersection of faith and the paranormal.
Wanna support the work?
Buymeacoffee.com/thedancingtoaster
Or head over to the Patreon if you want access to the new member exclusive show: The Man-Eating Toaster